No. In fact, the report, commissioned in secret by ISRO Chairman Dr. Radhakrishnan and completed in May 2010, found no fault in Devas’ conduct in reaching the Agreement and did not report any fraud involving its formation.
Moreover, the report found no suggestion of military need for S-band spectrum that could justify termination of the Agreement, and concluded there was “absolutely no doubt on the technical soundness of the digital multimedia services as proposed in this hybrid satellite and terrestrial system.”(1)
- UNCITRAL Award on Quantum to Mauritian shareholders of Devas, Paragraph 93.